What should I be doing instead of this?
Home · Articles · Screens · Movies · Earth (Review)

Earth (Review)

By Scott Renshaw · April 22nd, 2009 · Movies

Sixty years ago, Disney’s True-Life Adventures blazed the trail for nature filmmaking. Today, after basic cable and other family-friendly documentaries have picked up the slack, it feels like the company’s bringing up the rear.

Co-directors Alastair Fothergill and Mark Linfield fashion a “year in the life of the planet,” spanning the globe for epic tales of survival (and cute babies) narrated by James Earl Jones. Stories of parent-child journeys involving polar bears, humpback whales and elephants provide the narrative backbone, but Earth attempts to cover a lot of additional ground — warning of climate change, observing time-lapse images of changing seasons, soaring shots of thundering herds and crashing waterfalls.

And without a clear identity, it’s often merely a reminder of things that IMAX documentaries Arctic Tale, Winged Migration and even Discovery Channel’s Shark Week have done better. It plays like a sampler platter of the last 30 years of nature docs.

It’s not that Earth can’t manage a few gripping moments. There’s great night-vision footage of a pride of lions taking down a full-grown elephant and terrific footage of preening New Guinean birds of paradise. But it might actually be most fascinating watching the filmmakers at their risk-taking work during the closing credits.

Maybe the commitment of people who still want to show us the world’s wonders is a true-life adventure that would really feel new. Grade: C

Opens April 22. Check out theaters and show times, see the film's trailer and find nearby bars and restaurants here.



comments powered by Disqus